In response to my highlighting on Facebook of an article by climatology researcher James Hansen, in which he denounces the Paris talks as a "fraud," my friend shared the following comment. Although he has given me permission to share this comment at The Wild Reed, he's asked to be identified simply as a "concerned citizen."
This Agreement represents an amazing renewal of faith in multilateralism to address some of the world's complex challenges (and not just for climate change but a whole range of global issues). It's far from a perfect deal but that's called compromise by every one of the 195 countries involved – and compromise is singularly the most critical aspect of any effort to combat any global issue (i.e. don't let the perfect be the enemy of the public good). Importantly, for the first time it has the entire world travelling in the same direction with a common goal and purpose (so, yes it can be done if pursued respectfully). Further, it has all of the international accountability and transparency needed to hold every country (not just a few) to their commitments.
This Agreement was always going to be a framework complemented by initial pledges of climate action (not the other way round), Importantly, the Agreement contains 'no backsliding' clauses ensuring the aggregate level of climate action submitted by nations is a 'floor' not a ceiling - and so nations will be required to 'progress' their commitments every five years (which will be subjected to expert international scrutiny) within a context of reaching climate neutrality (text says something like "balance between emissions and sinks") ... it's little understood, but this Agreement was always the start of a new approach to climate action, not the end game. The fact that long term climate goal of halting temperature rises to a floor of 2 degrees Celsius means that the ceiling of 1.5 is the focus. Net negative emissions/climate neutrality has been now universally accepted as being essential (consistent with the IPCC findings) because at current levels of emissions, we will have used what carbon budget remains within 30 years.
Above: Part of the Vatican's December 8 light show, about which Carolyn Wickware of The Catholic Herald writes:
The opening of the Holy Year of Mercy culminated in a nature-inspired light show, with images of animals and the natural world projected onto the facade of St Peter’s Basilica yesterday evening.
Inspired by Pope Francis’s encyclical Laudato Si': On Care of our Common Home, changing images of endangered animals and nature were projected on the basilica in a three-hour event entitled Fiat Lux: Illuminating Our Common Home.
The show featured images by renowned nature photographers and filmmakers including Joel Sartore from National Geographic.
Writing for the Religion News Service, David Gibson notes that "Pope Francis hopes [the images] will inspire people — and negotiators at the climate change conference in Paris — to battle global warming and protect the environment."
Related Off-site Links:
Nearly 200 Nations Join Together to Fight Climate Change in Historic Paris Agreement – Alexandra Zavis, Chris Megerian and William Yardley (Los Angeles Times, December 12, 2015).
The 5 Most Important Components of the Paris Climate Agreement – Andrew Freedman (Mashable, December 13, 2015)
World Leaders Just Agreed to a Landmark Deal to Fight Global Warming . . . But Will It Be Enough? – Tim McDonnell and James West (Mother Jones, December 12, 2015).
Historic Climate Deal Reached, But Campaigners Say the Work is Just Beginning – Andrea Germanos (Common Dreams, December 12, 2015).
Paris Deal: Epic Fail on a Planetary Scale – Danny Chivers and Jess Worth (The New Internationalist, December 12, 2015).
What If We Told You to Be Optimistic About Solving Climate Change? – Adele Peters (Co.Exist, December 10, 2015).
Climate Deal Sealed, Campaigners Say it's Time to Kick Corporate Polluters Out of Policy – Lauren McCauley (Common Dreams, December 13, 2015).
COP21: All Politics is Local – Daniel DiLeo (Political Theology Today, December 10, 2015).
Amazing Vatican Light Show Displays the Beauty of Creation – Millenial (December 9, 2015).
UPDATES: Here's What You Need to Know About the New Paris Climate Deal – Bec Crew (Science Alert, December 14, 2015).
Pope Francis Praises "Historic" Paris Climate Change Agreement – Inés San Martín (Crux, December 14, 2015).
A New World Beckons: The Future Belongs to Renewables – Michael T. Klare (TomDispatch.com via Common Dreams, December 14, 2015).
Leaders Sidestep Pentagon's Carbon Emissions at COP21 – Jessica Desvarieux (The Real News, December 14, 2015).
The Paris Climate Agreement Changes Everything – Jeff Goodell (Rolling Stone, December 14, 2015).
Paris Agreement Will Not Stop Climate Change, But People Power Can – Jagoda Munic (Common Dreams, December 14, 2015).
Regarding the Paris Accord, One Word: Displacement – Harrison Beck (Star Tribune, December 14, 2015).
Claim No Easy Victories: Paris Was a Failure, But a Climate Justice Movement is Rising – Martin Lukacs (Common Dreams, December 14, 2015).
See also the previous Wild Reed posts:
• Something to Think About – October 13, 2015
• Words of Wisdom on Indigenous Peoples Day
• Earth Day 2015
• Quote of the Day – September 19, 2014
• Photo of the Day – Earth Day 2013
• Superstorm Sandy: A "Wake-Up Call" on Climate Change
• Quote of the Day – May 31, 2011